06.22.2004:SUPREME COURT OF UNITED STATES REVERSES RELEASE OF SALLY MCNEIL!
Tuesday, June 22, 2004 at 12:11 Supreme Court reinstates wife's conviction in killing of bodybuilder
By Associated Press
Monday, May 3, 2004
[SPECIAL BLOG INSERT: CLICK HERE ,READ 9TH CIRCUIT OPINION THAT ORIGINALLY SET SALLY FREE.]
[femalemuscle.com tribute to sally mcneil from several years ago and her poetry...click here
WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court reinstated a murder conviction Monday in the case of a California woman who claimed she shot her husband to end his physical and sexual abuse.
Sally McNeil was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to 15 years in prison. The case is Middleton v. McNeil, 03-1028.



Reader Comments (10)
He lived long enough, to tell the police that he was cooking chicken when he was shot, the first blast did not kill him, so she ran into the bedroom, where she ejected the other shell and reloaded another shell to shoot him, a second time in the face.
It was the ejected shell left in the bedroom that got her convicted, as well as the constant calls to the insurance company, prior to the murder, and while she was in jail to confirm that she would still receive the insurance money.
I didnt write this to be a hatchet job on Sally. Ray cheated on Sally, quite a bit, and it was Sally who worked to support the family, it was Sally who sacrificed her own career to support the family and that has to be acknowledged.
Yet, all you know the concocted story, you know the made for TV story, designed to get Sally off of murder, but had you asked anyone, anyone who knew the two of them this thread, written to mark some supposed injustice would never have been erected. It is a terrible display to mark a murderer attempting to sway the opinions of the many...
I do not know the full story, nor the story of her life that led to the murder. However, I'm no longer believe his physical abuse alone (if true) is the cause for her killing him. It takes a very twisted, premeditated mind to take a gun, shoot someone, re-load the gun, and shoot him again. And it wasn't in self-defense, contrary to Femalemuscle.com tribute. A battered woman, even a bodybuilder, wouldn't have the nerve to shoot someone. She's too afraid for her own life to want to take another's. The most she can do (usually) is run away. In most reported cases of spousal murders, they are motivated either by jealousy (of extramarital affair) or money (to claim insurance).
While the purpose of the website in empowering female bodybuilders be respected, I do insist that the authors check and re-check the facts before painting them as tragic saints. Frankly, I wonder about the credentials of the authors when they do such white-washing or glossy profiles of female bodybuilders involved with a crime. Sally McNeil is no saint. Neither are Graig Titus or Kelly Ryan.
Was wondering how she turned out and just learned of this yesterday, so I had to research my friend's words to see if they were true. They were. I'm not surprised what's become of her. Let the bitch rot in jail.